“Fair” doesn’t always mean “equal.” And when it comes to customer experience (CX), treating every customer the same might feel like a noble approach—but it’s often a costly mistake.
In today’s hyper-competitive, digitally connected world, customers expect relevance, responsiveness, and personalisation. Yet many organisations fall into the trap of uniformity, offering the same level of service, attention, and resources across their entire customer base. The result? Missed opportunities, inefficient resource allocation, and a CX strategy that fails to deliver impact where it matters most.
It’s time to challenge the idea that fairness in CX means treating everyone identically. Because when businesses start differentiating based on value, fit, and potential, that’s when real growth begins.
One-Size-Fits-All CX: A Comfortable Mistake
The instinct to offer consistent experiences across the board is understandable. Businesses want to be seen as fair, reliable, and customer-centric. But here’s the problem: not all customers are created equal—and their journeys, needs, and contributions to your business vary widely.
When you give everyone the same:
-
You risk underserving high-value clients, who expect more and are willing to reward brands that deliver it.
-
You overserve low-fit customers, investing time and resources into relationships that may not deliver ROI.
-
And you miss the chance to nurture promising segments who could become your next top-tier accounts with the right support.
Uniform CX often leads to mediocrity—where no one is disappointed, but no one is delighted either.
ICPs: Your Blueprint for Smarter CX
Enter the Ideal Customer Profile (ICP).
An ICP isn’t just a marketing concept. It’s a strategic tool that helps organisations define the types of customers who bring the greatest value to the business—not just in revenue, but in alignment, longevity, and growth potential.
A well-defined ICP considers:
-
Customer needs and challenges
-
Behavioural patterns and buying signals
-
Revenue potential and profitability
-
Strategic alignment with your product or service
-
Likelihood of advocacy and retention
By mapping out clear ICPs, businesses can move beyond “everyone’s a customer” to “these are the customers we’re built to serve best.” That shift opens the door to CX strategies that are tailored, efficient, and deeply impactful.
Tiered CX: Designing for Value, Not Uniformity
With ICPs in place, businesses can create tiered CX models—where experiences are intentionally designed to reflect customer value and potential.
Here’s how that might look:
🎯 Tier 1: High-Value, High-Fit Customers
-
Personalised onboarding and proactive support
-
Dedicated account managers or service teams
-
Early access to new features or offerings
-
Strategic check-ins to deepen the relationship
These customers are your champions. They drive revenue, influence others, and help shape your roadmap. Invest in them accordingly.
📈 Tier 2: High-Potential or Growth Customers
-
Scalable but semi-personalised journeys
-
Smart automation with periodic human touchpoints
-
Targeted education and enablement resources
These customers aren’t top-tier yet, but they could be. Show them their potential with you is worth investing in.
🧩 Tier 3: Low-Fit or Resource-Heavy Customers
-
Streamlined onboarding and self-service portals
-
Clear guidance on how to get value independently
-
Cost-effective support channels like chatbots or help centers
These customers may not be the right fit long-term. Support them with efficiency, not excessive effort.
Differentiation isn’t exclusion—it’s focus. By aligning your effort with value, you serve everyone more appropriately and sustainably.
ICP-Led CX: A Business-Wide Advantage
When ICPs inform your CX, it doesn’t just benefit customer service. It creates alignment across the business:
-
Marketing knows who to attract and how to speak their language.
-
Sales knows which leads to prioritise—and which to avoid chasing.
-
Product builds features that matter most to your best-fit customers.
-
Customer Success and Support can tailor their energy toward clients who’ll grow with the brand.
You reduce internal friction, shorten feedback loops, and boost satisfaction—internally and externally.
It also helps with measurement. You stop tracking meaningless averages and start understanding what matters within each tier. NPS or CSAT scores become more insightful when segmented by customer type.
What Equal Treatment Costs You
The cost of undifferentiated CX is real—and often invisible until it snowballs.
Consider this:
-
Your top-tier clients feel neglected and start exploring competitors who offer more personalised support.
-
Your team spends hours supporting clients who churn quickly or nickel-and-dime your value.
-
Your roadmap becomes bloated trying to serve every feature request, instead of prioritising what matters to strategic customers.
-
Your average satisfaction scores are “okay,” but advocacy and growth are flat.
It’s not that you’re failing—it’s that you’re failing to focus.
Real Growth Comes from Strategic Experience
What happens when businesses get this right?
They see:
-
Higher retention and lifetime value among their best-fit customers
-
Clearer pipeline focus and better deal close rates
-
More word-of-mouth advocacy and referrals
-
Stronger team alignment around what good looks like
And perhaps most importantly, they create room to breathe. No more trying to be everything to everyone. No more firefighting with customers who drain resources. Just smart, focused experience delivery that honours the value each customer brings—and has the potential to bring.
Rethinking Fairness in CX
Fair doesn’t mean everyone gets the same thing. Fair means everyone gets what they need to succeed—with your brand, your product, and your people.
It’s time to rethink your CX strategy. Are you giving equal attention, or appropriate attention? Are your best customers getting your best? Are you guiding your high-potential segments into growth?
Uniformity may feel safe—but it isn’t strategic. And in today’s experience economy, strategy wins.
Final Thought
Start with this simple question:
If you had to double down on 20% of your customers to drive 80% of your future growth—do you know who they are?
If not, defining your ICPs and aligning your CX around them isn’t just an opportunity. It’s a necessity.
Follow us on LinkedIn to get daily insights, download some of our amazing e-books HERE or simply Give us a call.